Device Reviews

Disclosure: This page contains affiliate links. If you purchase through these links, Rental Home Automator may earn a commission at no additional cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

ThirdReality Smart Plug Gen2

The ThirdReality Smart Plug Gen2 is an affordable Zigbee smart plug with energy monitoring and mesh-network repeating capabilities. On paper, it offers everything we’d want from a budget smart plug for a short-term rental.

Unfortunately, our experience with the Gen2 was disappointing, particularly when pairing it with our Zigbee network and testing its behavior following power interruptions.

Although the plug is inexpensive and offers useful functionality, these shortcomings make it difficult for us to recommend for an unattended rental property.

ThirdReality has since introduced the significantly improved Gen3, which we’ve also tested and would strongly recommend over this older model.

Our verdict: Not recommended for new installations. Choose the ThirdReality Gen3 instead.

Zigbee Connectivity and Pairing

The Gen2 uses Zigbee 3.0, allowing it to communicate with compatible smart-home hubs without connecting directly to the property’s Wi-Fi network.

It also functions as a Zigbee repeater, helping extend the network for other compatible devices. This is a useful feature when building a smart-home system with multiple sensors throughout a rental property.

Unfortunately, we encountered difficulties getting the Gen2 properly paired with our Zigbee network.

While we eventually got it working, setup wasn’t as straightforward or consistent as we’ve experienced with many competing devices.

That’s frustrating for rental owners who may be installing several smart plugs across multiple properties.

The newer Gen3 has been noticeably easier to pair and more dependable in our testing.

Power Restoration: Our Biggest Complaint

The most significant issue we experienced with the Gen2 was its inability to reliably restore its previous power state after an interruption.

For a smart plug at a rental property, we want it to remember whether it was on or off before losing power.

If the plug was on before an outage, it should return on when electricity is restored. If it was off, it should remain off.

In our testing, the Gen2 did not reliably preserve that previous state.

This is especially problematic for unattended rental properties. A power interruption shouldn’t unexpectedly turn on equipment that was intentionally off or leave previously running equipment without power.

ThirdReality documents configurable power-restoration functionality for certain hubs and integrations. However, the Gen2 did not deliver the behavior we wanted in our setup, and we wouldn’t rely on it for this purpose.

The newer Gen3 has performed much better in our testing and appears to address this concern.

Energy Monitoring and Automation

One feature we do appreciate is the Gen2’s built-in energy monitoring.

The plug can report electrical consumption through compatible smart-home platforms, making it useful for understanding how much power a connected device uses.

It also supports remote on/off control and can participate in supported Zigbee automation routines.

These features are useful for controlling lamps, decorative lighting, and other noncritical electrical devices at a short-term rental.

However, reliable switching and predictable recovery after an outage are more important to us than additional features.

Even an inexpensive smart plug becomes a poor investment if it introduces uncertainty into a remotely managed property.

For a broader explanation of why we prefer Zigbee and other hub-based protocols, read our guide to smart-home automation protocols for short-term rentals.

Gen2 vs. Gen3: Which Would We Buy?

Having tested both generations, the decision is easy.

The Gen3 is a substantial improvement over the Gen2. We’ve experienced easier Zigbee pairing, better connectivity, and more dependable behavior after power interruptions.

It also includes energy monitoring and upgraded Zigbee hardware, making it a compelling budget option for properties that already use Zigbee.

We still prefer the Eve Energy Smart Plug overall because of its superior build quality and excellent reliability. However, Eve uses Matter over Thread, so ThirdReality Gen3 is particularly attractive when Zigbee is the preferred protocol.

Given the improvements in the newer model, we see little reason to purchase Gen2 today.

Final Verdict

The ThirdReality Smart Plug Gen2 offers good value on paper, with Zigbee connectivity, energy monitoring, and repeating capabilities at an affordable price.

However, our hands-on experience revealed two weaknesses we consider important: inconsistent pairing and unreliable restoration of its previous on/off state following a power interruption.

Neither issue makes it an unusable smart plug, but both reduce our confidence in deploying it at a rental property that may be unattended for extended periods.

We don’t recommend the ThirdReality Smart Plug Gen2 for new installations.

Instead, we’d choose the improved ThirdReality Smart Plug Gen3 for affordable Zigbee switching or the Eve Energy for our preferred premium smart plug.

Rental Home Automator

ThirdReality Smart Plug Gen2 Review

The ThirdReality Smart Plug Gen2 offers affordable Zigbee switching and energy monitoring, but pairing difficulties and unreliable power-state restoration after outages limit its suitability for short-term rentals. The newer Gen3 addresses these concerns and is our recommended ThirdReality smart plug.
6/10
Total Score
  • Cost
    9/10
    Affordable with energy monitoring
  • Suitability for STRs
    4/10
    Unreliable restoration of previous power state
  • Reliability
    5/10
    Zigbee pairing difficulties in our testing
  • Usability
    6/10
    Useful basic features, but setup and outage behavior are frustrating

The Good

  • Affordable pricing
  • Zigbee 3.0 connectivity
  • Built-in energy monitoring
  • Zigbee mesh repeating

The Bad

  • Difficult Zigbee pairing
  • Did not reliably restore previous state after an outage
  • Less suitable for unattended rentals

About our reviews: We test and evaluate smart-home devices specifically for short-term rental use. Our goal is to help hosts choose equipment that is reliable, secure, and compatible with rental automation. Rental Home Automator is our software platform, so our recommendations also consider how devices fit into an automated rental setup.

Other Device Reviews